Top 13 Jewelry Stores in NYC

Marilyn Monroe told us diamonds are a girl’s best friend back in 1953, but the phrase is still relevant today. Women love their accessories and crave the perfect necklace or pair of earrings to match every outfit in their closet. Check out these thirteen jewelry stores around NYC so you can find your new best friend.

1. Erie Basin’s Red Hook Shop: 388 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn

Subscribe and be part of our commuinity.

Our top editors give you the stories, recommendations and honest reviews you need and want - delivered right to your inbox.

Privacy Notice: Newsletters may contain info about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. For more information see our Privacy Policy. We use Google reCaptcha to protect our website and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Subscribe and be the part of our commuinity.

Our top editors give you the stories, recommendations and honest reviews you need and want - delivered right to your inbox.

$1,250 Available at Erie Basin
$1,250 Available at Erie Basin

Here, you can shop by era, including Victorian, Art Deco and Retro & Modern to find that broach you’ve been wanting for months. The owner comes across beautiful antique items and loves to share them with his customers.

2. Elleven: 168 Court St, Brooklyn

$2,600 Available at Elleven
$2,600 Available at Elleven

Elleven offers custom jewelry; their website states, “We collaborate and create a variety of custom work, bring us your idea and we’ll make it happen!” In addition to that, they have an extensive engagement ring collection… So tell your guy to head here if he’s going to pop the question anytime soon.

3. Thistle & Clover: 221 Dekalb Ave, New York

$995 Available at Thistle Clover
$995 Available at Thistle & Clover

Just as much as it is a clothing store, it has a complete jewelry collection. This store carries a couple local designers such as Blanca Monros Gomez and Bittersweets NY. Also, there are men/unisex jewelry available!

4. Scosha: 64 Grand St, Brooklyn

$580 Available at Scosha
$580 Available at Scosha

Owner and designer Scosha Woolridge designs her jewelry based on her experiences traveling the world, such as designing her first pair of earrings after a young girl she met with freshly pierced ears in India. She puts precious and semi-precious jewels together in colorful and unexpected ways to make her jewelry one of a kind.

5. Catbird: 219 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn

$3,400 Available at Catbird
$3,400 Available at Catbird

Their namesake line features thin, stackable rings, delicate chain bracelets and tons of cute patterns such as anchors, hearts, and stars. Jewelry made and sold here can even be seen in different publications, such as PORTER Magazine.

6. Nora Kogan: 103 Metropolitan Avenue, Brooklyn

$2,265 Available at Nora Kogan
$2,265 Available at Nora Kogan

Open since 2004, Kogan handcrafts her jewelry here in New York where her goal is to make jewelry that outlives trends. Find everything and anything your heart desires at this store, from snake shaped ear cuffs to red lip bracelets.

7. Mociun: 224 Wythe, Brooklyn

$655 Available at Mociun
$655 Available at Mociun

Known for their one-of-a-kind stone cluster rings, often using antique diamonds and rare stones such as bicolor sapphires that are bound to catch anyone’s eye that walks past the window shop.

8. Anna Sheffield Jewelry: 47 Orchard St, New York

$4,000 Available at Anna Sheffield
$4,000 Available at Anna Sheffield

New Mexico inspired designs, like black diamond bands and emerald-cut moonstone rings, gives the jewelry a romantic feel with an edge. Sheffield expresses herself and her fine arts background through her beautiful jewelry.

9. Erica Weiner: 173 Elizabeth St, New York

$95 Available at Erica Weiner
$95 Available at Erica Weiner

With all of her jewelry in the EW collection under $200, you’ll be sure to have that gorgeous necklace and still stay on budget. They recently added antique jewelry and engagement/wedding bands to their inventory, so now they have everything under the moon.

10. Aesa: 35 Crosby St, New York

via Aesa Jewelry
Image: Via Aesa Jewelry

Focusing on geometric shapes, jewelry made here will make that silent statement you’ve been wanting for. You can expect brass, sterling silver an agate materials.

11. Melissa Joy Manning: 12 Wooster Street, New York

$7,500 Available at Melissa Joy Manning
$7,500 Available at Melissa Joy Manning

One of the few jewelry stores that thrives on being eco-friendly, MJM is “interested in creating a luxurious example of sustainability.” Manning receives inspiration for her jewelery from Death Valley, Iceland, Bali and Morocco.

12. Broken English: 56 Crosby St, New York

Broken English
$5,120 Available at Broken English

Originally established in Los Angeles, CA, this store sells contemporary fine and rare vintage jewelry. With different trends every month (chokers, festival, sunsets, or stars & stripes), you can find all type of necklaces, rings and earrings to fit the exact look you’re going for.

13. In God We Trust: 265 Lafayette St, New York

$5,135 Available at In God We Trust
$5,135 Available at In God We Trust

All handmade jewelry made in Brooklyn, this is a perfect place for BFF necklaces and engraved jewelry since you can have almost anything custom made to fit your needs. Jewelry as well as accessorizes are sold here for women and men.

1 Comment
    • Lauren Buckley
    • July 17, 2015
    • Reply

    I was just discussing with my boyfriend how I have no nice jewelry, my left hand is especially lonely 🙂 lol great job on your article Gabby. So proud to see my girls getting out in the world and doing something they love! ♡

Leave a Comment